中文题名: | 论环境犯罪合规不起诉制度中的行刑衔接机制及其完善 |
姓名: | |
保密级别: | 公开 |
论文语种: | chi |
学科代码: | 030104 |
学科专业: | |
学生类型: | 硕士 |
学位: | 法学硕士 |
学位类型: | |
学位年度: | 2023 |
校区: | |
学院: | |
研究方向: | 合规 |
第一导师姓名: | |
第一导师单位: | |
提交日期: | 2023-06-23 |
答辩日期: | 2023-05-26 |
外文题名: | ON THE IMPLEMENTATION LINKAGE MECHANISM AND ITS IMPROVEMENT IN THE ENVIRONMENTAL CRIME COMPLIANCE NON- PROSECUTION SYSTEM |
中文关键词: | |
外文关键词: | : Environmental Crime ; Unification of Criminal and AdministrativeEnforcement ; Non-Prosecution ; Compliance Incentive ; Public Interest litigation ; Criminal law for the people's livelihood |
中文摘要: |
环境犯罪合规不起诉制度系环境合规概念的衍生形态,以双向行刑衔接机制为依托通过合规考察机制、合规有效性审查机制以及合规监督机制,对环境犯罪企业实施合规激励裁量。正向衔接中,检察机关协同生态环境部门以前置环境行政法定性以及后续环境刑法定量相衔接为认定模式;反向衔接中,检察机关通过制发检察意见向行政延伸,对不起诉企业进行行政处罚必要性审查与行政处罚合法性和合理性监督。环境犯罪的双重违法性和责任性要求环境犯罪合规不起诉制度的构建须以法秩序统一性为原则和行刑一体化为思维。在环境行刑衔接机制的法理逻辑中,正向衔接以责任主义视角展开,体现环境犯罪认定与责任追究的行刑双重属性;反向衔接由检察监督权规制环境行政执法,以柔性制发检察意见或提出建议、刚性提起环境公益诉讼等方式监管环境行政治理;受民生刑法理论影响,环境刑法立法扩张保护环境民生权益,合规整改充实环境制裁方式,环境司法限缩调控刑法边界,相称性原则调整合规整改负担;环境哲学的代内代际视野要求环境刑法回归环境违法犯罪责任认定的本质特征,善用环境合规行刑衔接机制联结环境刑罚威慑、非刑罚制裁、环境公益诉讼制约等方式共同完成“历时性”的生态环境保护治理。 目前,环境合规行刑衔接机制的法治困境具体为环境犯罪法律规制体系在保护法益和主观罪过方面缺乏行刑一体化思维;环境合规行刑激励机制欠缺体系性,环境行政处罚严厉性强化导致刑事合规激励或有虚化风险;行刑反向衔接机制制度化建设不足,企业环境合规整改标准与成果亟待行刑互通互认;环境合规行刑责任衔接规范不充分,新《生态环境行政处罚法(修订意见)》树立环境行政合规激励规范,但环境刑法未明确合规不起诉制度合法化基础,易引发环境合规行刑责任衔接断层。 为完善环境合规行刑衔接机制,责任衔接层面,应协调环境违法与环境犯罪的责任的位阶对接;激励衔接层面,环境立法应秉持系统性合规激励主义;制度衔接层面,构建行刑联动治理的环境合规法律框架,推进环境公益诉讼与环境合规不起诉同步办理;规范衔接层面,充实环境合规不起诉制度行刑规范,增强环境刑法实体依据,并提高行刑衔接规范的效力层级。 |
外文摘要: |
The environmental crime compliance non prosecution system is a derivative form of the concept of environmental compliance, relying on a two-way execution linkage mechanism to implement compliance incentive and discretion for environmental crime enterprises through compliance inspection mechanisms, compliance effectiveness review mechanisms, and compliance supervision mechanisms. In the positive connection, the procuratorial organs collaborate with the ecological and environmental departments to establish a recognition model that combines the legality of the pre environmental administrative law with the quantitative connection of the subsequent environmental criminal law; In the reverse connection, the procuratorial organs extend to the administration through the issuance of procuratorial opinions, and the non litigation enterprises conduct necessary review of administrative penalties and supervision of the legality and rationality of administrative penalties. The dual illegality and responsibility of environmental crimes require that the compliance non prosecution system for environmental crimes should be based on the principle of unity of legal order and the integration of |
参考文献总数: | 88 |
作者简介: | 黄曼庭,女,北京师范大学法学院刑法学硕士,研究方向为刑法学。 |
馆藏号: | 硕030104/23008 |
开放日期: | 2024-06-22 |