Antimony (Sb) and arsenic (As) are typical toxic metalloid elements in the surface environment, and they usually coexist together to form compound pollution. With the intensification of industrial activities such as mining and smelting, Sb and As are released into the surface environment to produce enrichment, and their geochemical behavior affects environmental safety and human health. Sb is a mineral resource with Chinese characteristics, and its reserves and output are the largest in the world. There are many superlarge Sb deposit zone located in the Zijiang River (ZR) Basin, such as the Longshan Sb-Au deposit, Xikuangshan Sb deposit, Gutaishan Sb deposit, Zhazixi Sb deposit, and Banxi Sb deposit. Due to the influence of mining activities, the pollution of Sb and As in the water bodies of the ZR Basin is prominent. As priority pollutants, the geochemical behavior and environmental effects of Sb and As have received extensive attention worldwide. There are spatial differences in the concentration distribution of metals under the changing environmental conditions (runoff, sedimentary environment, pollution sources, etc.) from the mine tributaries to the mainstream of ZR. However, systematic studies of Sb and As under such changing environmental conditions are still lacking, and it is crucial to study the concentration characteristics and the environmental geochemical behavior of Sb and As in specific water environments.
In this study, the ZR water body was selected as the research object, and the spatial and temporal distribution and allocation of Sb and As in water bodies, as well as the characteristics of Sb isotope fractionation in sediments, were systematically studied by combining field sampling, indoor environmental chemical experiments, and modern instrumental analysis (such as multicollector‒inductively coupled plasma‒mass spectrometry), and the potential ecological and health risks of Sb and As were evaluated. The fraction transformation and dynamic release paths of Sb and As were clarified, and the migration processes of Sb and As in different environmental conditions were compared. The research results supplemented the regional basic research data of Sb and As, revealed the environmental geochemical processes of Sb and As, and provided a scientific reference for the pollution control of Sb and As at the basin scale, which has important scientific significance. The main results of this study are as follows:
(1) Occurrence characteristics: The average concentrations of Sb and As in the waters from the mainstream of ZR were 4.29 μg/L and 2.75 μg/L, respectively, and the concentration of Sb showed spatial and temporal differences, while As did not show significant spatial differences. The average concentrations of Sb and As in surface sediments of the mainstream of ZR were 34.19 mg/kg and 33.61 mg/kg, respectively, corresponding to the average concentrations of Sb and As in pore water of 13.26 μg/L and 42.78 μg/L, respectively, with large spatial variability, and the Zhexi Dam had led to the accumulation of Sb and As in the midstream and the decrease in the downstream. The concentrations of Sb and As in the waters from the tributaries of the mining area were strongly regulated by the Sb mining and smelting activities, showing a trend of attenuation with distance in the river, and its concentrations were generally higher than those in the mainstream of ZR. However, in the sediment of tributaries in the mining area, except for the Sb and As concentrations in the Lianxi River in Xikuangshan, which were significantly higher than those in the mainstream of ZR, the Sb and As concentrations in the sediment and pore water of other tributaries were either equal to or lower than those in the mainstream of ZR. The Sb and As concentrations in the sediment of each tributary did not decrease with the decrease in distance from ZR, which was related to the scouring environment formed by strong hydrodynamic forces. There was a clear trend of attenuation of Sb in the five sedimentary profiles with distance along the flow direction of the mining area-ZR-Dongting Lake. The vertical distribution of Sb and As in the same sedimentary profile was not completely the same. In summary, the concentrations of Sb and As in the waters of the tributaries of the mining area were higher than that of the mainstream of ZR, while the concentrations of Sb and As in sediments (except for the Lianxi River) were equivalent and were influenced by the inflow of Xikangshan tributaries and the regulation of sediment deposition the Zhexi dam.
(2) Allocation rules: Sb and As in waters mainly existed in dissolved form, with sediment-pore water partition coefficients of 2.95–4.18 and 2.53–4.01, respectively, and Sb and As in sediments were more likely to combine with solids and mainly existed in the residual fraction. The proportion of residual fraction in Sb was ≥ 92.39%, which is higher than that in As (≥ 65.52%). The proportion of bioavailable concentration in As was higher than that in Sb. The distribution of Sb and As in the solid and pore water phases of surface sediments was mainly influenced by the presence of Ca and Fe/Al oxides in the sediments. The relationship between Sb in profile samples and environmental factors was not significant, while As was affected by organic matter and Al-Fe-Mn oxides. The concentrations of different fractions of Sb and As in sediment were controlled by their total concentrations, maintaining a dynamic equilibrium relationship. Dynamic transfer occurs mainly through linear and nonlinear combinations of pathways. Human activities can accelerate the process of transforming residual Sb and As into other active components, with Sb having a lower mobility than As. In the mainstream of ZR sediments, the ε123Sb value was lower than that of the tributaries in the mining area, and simple dilution of Sb along the river and adsorption of Fe-Al oxides in the sediment did not result in significant Sb isotopic fractionation in the sediment. Sb was transported conservatively along the river. The differences in ε123Sb values across regions make Sb isotopic composition a potentially useful tool for tracing the source of Sb in the water system and studying biogeochemical processes. Human activities that disrupt the stability of sediments (such as sand mining) should be minimized to avoid increased Sb, especially As released and its mobility, which can cause more severe environmental effects.
(3) Risk assessment: The risk of Sb contamination in the ZR basin was higher than that of As, and there was little contamination in the waters, while contamination in the sediment was universal. Based on the total concentration evaluation method, the ecological risk of Sb in sediment was higher than that of As, but the assessment based on the speciation showed that the ecological risk of As was higher than that of Sb, which was because most Sb existed in the residual fraction, leading to an overestimation of the ecological risk of Sb based on total concentration evaluation, while the high available concentration of As led to an overestimation of the ecological risk of As based only on chemical form evaluation. Overall, there was high contamination and ecological risk of Sb and As in the sediment of the midstream of ZR and Lianxi River, which is related to the mining activities in Xikuangshan being transported to Lianxi River and then transported to the mainstream of ZR at a long distance. The health risks from Sb and As in waters were generally low, but sediment exposure had increased the overall health risk of As in ZR, with children's health risk being higher than adults. The high risks in the sediments of the midstream of ZR and Xikuangshan should be focused on, and the ecological risk levels of Sb and As in sediments assessed based on total concentration and speciation methods were opposite, indicating that multi-index comprehensive analysis is necessary to increase the reliability of risk assessment for Sb and As in river basins.
This study has achieved some innovative results in the following three aspects: (1) the distribution and long-distance migration of Sb and As in rivers at the basin scale, (2) isotope composition and fractionation characteristics of Sb in river sediments, and (3) comprehensive risk assessment of Sb and As in water bodies. This study not only deepened the understanding of the spatio-temporal changes of elements in the water environment and their influencing factors, but also made up for the deficiency of regional Sb isotope basic data, enriched the Sb isotope fingerprint database, and provided a guarantee for the reliability of Sb and As risk assessment in the basin.