- 无标题文档
查看论文信息

中文题名:

 《经义述闻·春秋左传》研究    

姓名:

 彭淦    

保密级别:

 公开    

论文语种:

 chi    

学科代码:

 060101    

学科专业:

 历史学    

学生类型:

 学士    

学位:

 历史学学士    

学位年度:

 2024    

校区:

 珠海校区培养    

学院:

 文理学院    

第一导师姓名:

 黄国辉    

第一导师单位:

 历史学院    

提交日期:

 2024-06-06    

答辩日期:

 2024-05-16    

外文题名:

 RESEARCH ON JING YI SHU WEN: THE SPRING AND AUTUMN ANNALS - ZUO ZHUAN    

中文关键词:

 王引之 ; 《经义述闻》 ; 《春秋左传》 ; 考据学    

外文关键词:

 Wang Yinzhi ; Jing Yi Shu Wen ; The Spring and Autumn Annals - Zuo Zhuan ; textual research    

中文摘要:

       《經義述聞》是王引之的代表著作,常被譽爲有清一代乾嘉考據學研究的扛鼎之作。其中《春秋左傳》三卷凡二百一十六則“述聞”條目,對《左傳》進行了翔實的考據,在考據學史和清代《左傳》學史上佔有一席之地。该文旨在深入剖析王氏对《左傳》的考據成果及其背後所蘊含的考據學思想,通過系統的歸納分類與細緻的分析,全面梳理氏著考據實踐,並期提出新見。

       首先,该文突破了過往學界對《經義述聞·春秋左傳》僅從訓詁學或校勘學角度研究的局限,將研究視角擴展到對氏著整體考據學思想體系的挖掘。通過對王氏“因聲求義”“憑語證義”“循字推義”“以意逆志”等考據方法的深入剖析,本文揭示了其在考據實踐中所體現出的嚴謹性、系統性和創新性,進而更為全面地展現王引之作為考據學家的學術風範和理論深度。

       其次,该文在探究王引之考據學思想與成就的同時,亦不忘對其考據成果進行批判性審視。本文指出了氏著對《左傳》的考據存在“濫辨音義,臆改古書”“以今律古,強爲之解”“以偏概全,泛而論之”等疏漏與不足,並通過舉例分析發現其考據失誤的主要原因在於兼籌並顧地運用考據方法而未能抓住主要矛盾。

       此外,该文還結合新近的出土文獻材料,對王引之考據《左傳》尚存爭議者——“王亦能軍”條、“弔二叔之不咸”條與“棠君尚”條三則進行了辨正,不僅增強了本文的學術價值,也為後續研究提供了寶貴的參考。

       最後,该文還簡要探討了《經義述聞·春秋左傳》與清代《左傳》學、出土文獻材料之間的關係。通過對比分析,本文辯證地揭示了王引之的考據學思想在清代《左傳》學發展過程中的重要地位,以及出土文獻材料對考據學研究的巨大推動作用,不僅拓寬了本文的研究視野,也為考據學研究的深入發展提供了新的思路。

外文摘要:

       Jing Yi Shu Wen is Wang Yinzhi's representative work, often hailed as a masterpiece of textual research during the Qianlong-Jiaqing period of the Qing Dynasty. His Jing Yi Shu Wen: The Spring and Autumn Annals - Zuo Zhuan consists of three volumes with 216 entries of "commentaries", providing detailed textual research on Zuo Zhuan, occupying a significant position in the history of textual research and the study of Zuo Zhuan in the Qing Dynasty. This paper aims to deeply analyze Wang's textual research achievements on Zuo Zhuan and the textual research thoughts behind them. Through systematic classification and detailed analysis, it comprehensively examines Wang's textual research practices and hopes to propose new insights in academia.

       Firstly, this paper breaks through the limitations of previous academic research on Jing Yi Shu Wen: The Spring and Autumn Annals - Zuo Zhuan solely from the perspectives of exegetics or collation, expanding the research perspective to explore Wang's overall textual research ideology. By deeply analyzing Wang's textual research methods such as "seeking meaning through sound", "proving meaning through language", "inferring meaning from characters", and "interpreting intention through context", this paper reveals the rigor, systematicness, and innovation embodied in his textual research practice, further showcasing Wang Yinzhi's academic style and theoretical depth as a textual scholar.

       Secondly, while exploring Wang Yinzhi's textual research thoughts and achievements, this paper also critically examines his textual research results. It points out shortcomings in Wang's textual research on Zuo Zhuan, such as "excessive discrimination of pronunciation and meaning, arbitrary alteration of ancient texts", "imposing modern standards on ancient texts, forcing explanations", and "generalizing based on partial evidence". Through example analysis, it finds that the main reason for his textual research errors lies in the simultaneous application of textual research methods without grasping the primary contradiction.

       Moreover, combining with newly unearthed literature materials, this paper clarifies three controversial textual research topics in Wang's study of Zuo Zhuan. This not only enhances the academic value of this paper but also provides valuable references for subsequent research.

       Finally, this paper briefly discusses the relationship between Jing Yi Shu Wen: The Spring and Autumn Annals - Zuo Zhuan, the study of Zuo Zhuan in the Qing Dynasty, and newly unearthed literature materials. Through comparative analysis, it dialectically reveals the important position of Wang Yinzhi's textual research thoughts in the development of Zuo Zhuan studies in the Qing Dynasty and the significant role of newly unearthed literature materials in promoting textual research studies. This not only broadens the research horizon of this paper but also provides new ideas for the in-depth development of textual research studies.

参考文献总数:

 95    

馆藏号:

 本060101/24062Z    

开放日期:

 2025-06-06    

无标题文档

   建议浏览器: 谷歌 360请用极速模式,双核浏览器请用极速模式